LTV Calculation Problems in New Service Launches

You've been tasked with calculating the lifetime value (LTV) for your organization's brand new healthcare service. Your leadership team is eager to understand which customer segments to prioritize, how much to spend on acquisition, and what ROI to expect. There's just one massive problem: you have no historical data to work with.

"How do they expect me to calculate LTV if it's a new service?" you wonder, staring at your empty spreadsheet. "Without churn rates or average revenue figures, I'm essentially making numbers up."

If this scenario feels painfully familiar, you're not alone. Data scientists and marketers across healthcare organizations struggle with this fundamental paradox: the metrics most valuable for strategic decision-making are often the least available when you need them most—at launch.

‍

Why Standard LTV Models Fail at Launch

Traditional LTV calculations rely heavily on historical performance data:

• Basic LTV = ARPU × Average Customer Lifespan
• Churn-based LTV = ARPU ÷ Churn Rate
• Advanced LTV = (ARPA × Gross Margin %) ÷ Revenue Churn Rate

The problem is immediately obvious. Every variable—Average Revenue Per User (ARPU), customer lifespan, churn rate—requires months or years of historical data that a new service simply doesn't have.

Even if you attempt to extrapolate from early data, the results can be dangerously misleading. Baremetrics analysis shows that in growing businesses, rapid influx of new customers heavily skews churn-based LTV calculations, potentially making them off by as much as 50%. As one frustrated data scientist noted on Reddit, "LTV is fairly useless for an early or mid-stage startup that hasn't reached a repeatable business model."

This problem is exponentially worse in healthcare, where customer "value" isn't a predictable monthly subscription but a complex interplay of health needs, insurance coverage, and economic factors.

‍

The Healthcare Context: When 'Value' Isn't Simple

Healthcare adds unique complications to LTV calculations:

1. Volatility of patient behavior: According to Kaiser Family Foundation data, 44% of U.S. adults find it difficult to afford healthcare costs, with 36% skipping or postponing care due to cost concerns. These aren't stable, predictable subscribers—they're individuals making difficult financial choices that directly impact their "value" to your service.
2. Complex revenue streams: Unlike subscription businesses where revenue is predictable, healthcare services often have variable reimbursement rates, unpredictable utilization patterns, and third-party payers.
3. Longer time horizons: The true "lifetime" value of a healthcare customer may take years to realize, especially for preventive or chronic care services where the benefits compound over time.

‍

From Predictive LTV to 'Impactable Healthcare Spend'

Rather than chasing a mythical LTV number, forward-thinking healthcare data scientists are pivoting to a more relevant metric: impactable healthcare spend.

Definition: The portion of a patient's total annual healthcare expenditure that your specific service can directly address, replace, or reduce.

This concept transforms your approach from "predicting lifetime value" to "identifying where we can make the most impact." Instead of seeking "high LTV" customers, you're targeting customers with "high impactable spend"—those whose healthcare costs could be meaningfully reduced or optimized by your service.

For example, if you're launching a remote monitoring service for patients with congestive heart failure, the impactable spend isn't their entire healthcare budget—it's the cost of their ER visits, hospital readmissions, and specialist appointments that your service aims to reduce.

Estimating Impactable Spend

To calculate impactable spend, combine:

1. Demographic data with claims data, EHR information, or survey responses to identify patient cohorts with specific conditions
2. Published cost studies for those conditions
3. Your service's proven or projected impact on reducing those costs

This approach provides a concrete, defensible metric that directly ties to your business model and value proposition.

‍

Actionable Alternatives: Strategic Segmentation

If you can't predict individual LTV, you can group prospective customers into value tiers based on proxies. This is the foundation of a data-driven strategy at launch.

Patient Segmentation as a Value Framework

The goal is to identify high-need, high-cost patients where your service can make the most impact. High-need adults can have annual healthcare spend exceeding $21,000—nearly three times the average for adults with multiple chronic diseases.

Follow this step-by-step process:

1. Create Patient Segmentation Groups: Define groups based on health needs, demographics, risk scores, and impactable spend estimates.
2. Utilize EHR Data and Analysis Tools: Leverage existing data using established methodologies like 3M Clinical Risk Groups (CRGs) or Johns Hopkins Adjusted Clinical Groups (ACGs).
3. Identify Segmentation Goals: Be specific about what you're trying to achieve (e.g., target patients at high risk for readmission).
4. Share Findings: Document and distribute your analysis to align sales, marketing, and clinical teams. To ensure consistent execution, an AI coaching platform like Hyperbound can help roll out targeted messaging for each patient segment, allowing reps to practice and master new approaches.

Focus on Short-Term, Actionable KPIs

Instead of fixating on LTV, track metrics that provide immediate feedback on strategy and market fit:

• Conversion Rate: By segment, by outreach strategy
• Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): How much does it cost to acquire a patient in each segment?
• Initial Engagement/Adoption: Are new patients actually using the service? How quickly?
• Short-Term Spend Impact: What is the actual revenue or cost-savings generated in the first 30-90 days?

While true LTV remains unknown, you can work toward the healthy LTV/CAC ratio of 3:1 recommended for profitable businesses. Use your impactable spend estimates as a proxy for LTV to see if your CAC is in a reasonable ballpark.

‍

Building Your Data Foundation: A/B Testing for Clarity

Your first A/B tests aren't about optimization—they're about generating baseline data. This addresses the core pain of having "no existing conversion rate benchmark."

A Structured Approach to Testing

1. Define Simple, Contrasting Strategies
2. Avoid testing "many segments at the same time," which leads to confusion. Instead, create clear, distinct hypotheses for your outbound calling or marketing approaches.
3. Example: Test "calling as many prospects as possible" vs. "prioritizing follow-up calls" for a specific patient segment. With AI sales roleplays, your team can practice both scenarios in a safe environment to master the nuances of each strategy before live calls.
4. Use Random Assignment
5. This is critical for valid results. Randomly assign prospects from your target list to either a control group (current strategy or no outreach) or an experiment group (new strategy).
6. As one data scientist advised on Reddit: "Randomly assign prospects to strategy A or B" to ensure statistical validity.
7. Measure Conversion Rate
8. The primary outcome is simple: what percentage of each group converted (scheduled an appointment, enrolled in service, etc.)? This gives you your first benchmark.
9. Implement Significance Testing (Carefully)
10. Address concerns about "over-testing" by focusing on one clear comparison at a time with a large enough sample. This approach helps ensure your differences in conversion rates are statistically significant and not due to random chance.
11. Remember that significance testing requires adequate sample sizes, which may mean running your test for longer periods in healthcare settings where conversion volumes can be lower than in consumer products.

Using A/B Testing Results to Refine Your Approach

Each test builds your knowledge base for future LTV modeling:

1. Identify High-Converting Segments: Which patient groups respond best to your outreach?
2. Optimize Acquisition Costs: Which strategies deliver conversions at the lowest cost?
3. Refine Your Value Proposition: Which messaging elements resonate most with different segments? Analyzing call data from your tests can reveal which phrases, questions, and value statements lead to higher conversion.
4. Build Your Data Foundation: Every test adds to your historical data set, gradually enabling more sophisticated LTV modeling.

‍

From Ambiguity to Action: A New Framework

The path forward for a new healthcare service launch isn't to invent an LTV number—it's to build a system for learning:

1. Acknowledge Limits: Recognize that churn-based LTV is not a reliable metric for a new service.
2. Use Proxies: Shift focus to tangible concepts like impactable healthcare spend and use patient segmentation to identify high-potential prospects.
3. Track What You Can Control: Measure short-term KPIs like conversion rate and CAC with rigorous A/B testing and random assignment to focal and control groups.
4. Build Your Model Over Time: The data collected becomes the foundation for increasingly sophisticated LTV models. You're building the historical data you wish you had from day one.

By guiding your organization away from a flawed metric and toward a structured process of learning and data collection, you provide far more value than a single, inaccurate LTV prediction ever could.

Remember: in new service launches, especially in healthcare, the goal isn't perfect prediction—it's data-informed action that builds the foundation for future success. Your sales strategy, segmentation approach, and conversion optimization now will create the historical data needed for accurate LTV calculations later.

As one experienced data scientist noted, "Even Finance doesn't expect it to be accurate, but to still be useful to make decisions." Your job isn't to predict the future with perfect accuracy—it's to provide the best possible framework for making decisions today while building toward better insights tomorrow.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is calculating LTV for a new healthcare service so difficult?

Calculating LTV for a new healthcare service is difficult primarily due to the lack of historical data. Traditional LTV models require stable figures for customer lifespan, churn rates, and average revenue per user (ARPU), none of which are available at launch. Using early data can be highly misleading as it often doesn't represent long-term customer behavior.

What is a better alternative to LTV for new healthcare services?

A more practical alternative is focusing on impactable healthcare spend. This metric represents the portion of a patient's total annual healthcare costs that your service can directly address, replace, or reduce. It shifts the focus from predicting future revenue to identifying current opportunities where your service can provide the most value, making it a more actionable metric for strategic planning at launch.

How can I estimate 'impactable healthcare spend' without historical data?

You can estimate impactable healthcare spend by combining publicly available information with internal analysis. This involves a three-step process: first, use demographic and claims data to identify patient cohorts with specific conditions; second, reference published cost studies to understand the average healthcare spend for these conditions; and third, calculate your service's potential to reduce those specific costs.

What key metrics should I track at launch instead of LTV?

Instead of a long-term LTV, you should track short-term, actionable Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that provide immediate feedback. The most important metrics include Conversion Rate (by segment and outreach strategy), Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC), Initial Engagement and Adoption rates, and the Short-Term Spend Impact (revenue or cost savings in the first 30-90 days).

How does patient segmentation help when LTV is unknown?

Patient segmentation allows you to group potential customers into value tiers based on proxies like health needs, risk scores, and estimated impactable spend. This is crucial when individual LTV is unknown because it helps you prioritize your sales and marketing efforts. By focusing on high-need, high-cost patient groups, you can target resources where your service can make the most significant impact and likely generate the most value.

When is it appropriate to start calculating a traditional LTV?

You can begin calculating a traditional LTV once your service has been operating long enough to accumulate sufficient and stable historical data. This typically takes several months to a few years, allowing you to establish reliable patterns in revenue, customer retention, and churn. The short-term KPIs and A/B testing data you collect from day one are essential for building the data foundation needed for this future LTV modeling.

‍