Beyond Surface Level: 3 Ways to Deepen Any Conversation

You're at a networking event, a friend's dinner party, or even a first date. The conversation starts predictably: "What do you do?" "Where are you from?" "Nice weather we're having..." And then it happens—the dreaded awkward silence. You've exhausted all the surface level conversations and now you're stuck, desperately searching for something meaningful to say.

It's a universal struggle. Many of us want deeper connections but fear that asking probing questions might make us seem intrusive or turn the interaction into an uncomfortable therapy session. As one Reddit user laments, "I feel that even with some of my best friends, I have never gone beyond surface-area topics," while another warns, "Some 'deep conversations' are a good way to make sure someone never wants to speak to you ever again."

But there's good news: deepening a conversation doesn't require awkward icebreakers or memorizing a list of intense deep questions. In fact, the most meaningful exchanges happen organically when we employ a few subtle techniques that encourage others to open up naturally.

This article provides three practical strategies to move beyond small talk without resorting to the stilted approaches that make you sound like a pickup artist or an amateur therapist. These techniques will help you create a natural flow of conversation that leads to meaningful connections while respecting social boundaries.

‍

1. The 'MythBuster' Approach: Ask About Professional Myths and Clichés

One of the most effective ways to deepen a conversation is to tap into someone's expertise and passion. Instead of the generic "What do you do?" question that typically yields a one-word job title, try this approach:

"What's a common cliché or well-defined myth in your field that you wish more people knew was false?"

This question works brilliantly for several reasons:

1. It positions the other person as an expert, which is naturally flattering
2. It invites them to share insider knowledge, which people typically enjoy doing
3. It often reveals their values and frustrations, creating a pathway to deeper discussion
4. It's professional rather than personal, making it appropriate even with new acquaintances

For example, if you're talking to someone in corporate communications, they might reveal that contrary to popular belief, "effective communication isn't about telling the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth." This could lead to a fascinating discussion about the ethics of information management and corporate transparency.

Or perhaps they'll debunk the myth that "email should be your primary workplace communication channel," opening up a conversation about how different communication methods serve different purposes and how workplace culture is evolving.

The beauty of the MythBuster approach is that it works across virtually any profession—from teachers to doctors, marketers to mechanics. Everyone has experienced misconceptions about their work, and most people appreciate the opportunity to set the record straight.

Unlike many conversation starters that feel forced, this question naturally leads to deeper territory without ever feeling like you're conducting a formal interview or trying to extract personal information inappropriately.

‍

2. The Art of the Follow-Up: Go Deeper, Not Wider

The secret to meaningful conversation isn't jumping from one deep question to another—it's exploring one topic thoroughly through skillful follow-up questions.

Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology reveals that people who ask more questions, particularly follow-up questions, are better liked by their conversation partners. This makes perfect sense: follow-up questions demonstrate that you're genuinely listening and interested in understanding more, not just waiting for your turn to speak.

Instead of asking a series of unrelated questions that can feel like an interrogation, try the "go deeper, not wider" approach with these effective follow-ups:

• "Can you tell me more about that?"
• "How did that make you feel?"
• "What about that field particularly interests you?"
• "How did you first learn about it?"
• "What made you feel that way?"

These questions encourage elaboration without feeling like therapeutic questions that might make someone uncomfortable. They're casual enough for everyday conversation but powerful enough to uncover meaningful insights.

One particularly effective technique is "looping for understanding," which involves two simple steps:

1. Paraphrase what you've heard in your own words: "So if I'm understanding correctly, you felt frustrated because the project changed direction without your input."
2. Ask for confirmation: "Is that right?"

This technique not only ensures you've understood correctly but also powerfully demonstrates that you're truly engaged in the conversation. It validates the speaker's perspective and often encourages them to elaborate further.

As one Reddit user advised, "Remember to paraphrase the question as if you're just articulating it and it's something you would say." This keeps the conversation feeling natural rather than scripted.

The follow-up approach works because it creates depth organically. Instead of jumping from topic to topic with the FORD method (Family, Occupation, Recreation, Dreams) in a superficial way, you're building understanding layer by layer. This creates the conditions for genuine connection without the awkward silence that often results from exhausting a list of prepared questions.

‍

3. Cultivate Genuine Curiosity (And How to Show It)

The first two techniques only work if they're backed by authentic interest. People have remarkable radar for detecting when someone is just following a conversational script versus when they're truly engaged. Cultivating and demonstrating genuine curiosity is perhaps the most important social skill for meaningful conversation.

Here's how to show genuine interest in ways that encourage others to open up naturally:

Practice Active Listening

Active listening goes beyond simply hearing words—it involves making a concerted effort to understand the meaning and emotion behind them. As Celeste Headlee explains in her popular TED talk on better conversations, "Don't multitask. Be present. And that means more than just putting down your phone."

This means:

• Focusing completely on the speaker instead of planning what you'll say next
• Noticing their tone, facial expressions, and body language
• Resisting the urge to interrupt with your own similar experiences
• Asking questions that clarify meaning rather than changing the subject

Use Non-Verbal Cues Intentionally

Your body language speaks volumes about your level of interest. When you:

• Maintain appropriate eye contact
• Nod occasionally to acknowledge understanding
• Orient your body toward the speaker
• Put away distractions like your phone

You signal that you value what they're saying. These non-verbal cues create psychological safety that encourages deeper sharing.

Offer Emotional Validation

One of the most powerful ways to deepen a conversation is to acknowledge the emotions behind what someone is sharing. Dr. Sabrina Romanoff, clinical psychologist, explains that "sharing and validating feelings creates a sense of emotional intimacy that transcends surface-level interactions."

Simple phrases like "That sounds incredibly challenging" or "I can see why you'd be proud of that accomplishment" show that you're engaging with the emotional content of the conversation, not just the facts.

This doesn't mean turning every chat into a therapy session—it simply means recognizing the human experience behind the words. When people feel their emotions are validated, they're more likely to share authentically.

Embrace Appropriate Vulnerability and Reciprocity

Meaningful conversations require a balance of sharing and listening. When someone opens up to you, reciprocate with a related experience of your own—but keep it proportional. This isn't about oversharing or dominating the conversation; it's about creating an exchange that feels mutual.

Research on interpersonal closeness, including the famous "36 Questions" study, demonstrates that gradually escalating self-disclosure builds intimacy naturally. You might share a brief personal reflection that relates to what they've just told you, then return the focus to them.

For example, if someone shares a professional challenge, you might briefly mention a similar obstacle you faced, then ask how they ultimately handled their situation. This balanced approach creates a conversation that feels like a genuine exchange rather than an interview.

The key to this technique is self-awareness—understanding when to share, when to listen, and how much to reveal based on the context and relationship. As one Reddit user wisely noted, "These questions are best for when a friendly relationship has been established," highlighting the importance of gauging appropriate depth based on your existing rapport.

‍

Putting It All Together

Moving beyond surface-level talk doesn't require memorizing a list of intense questions or forcing unwanted intimacy. Instead, it involves:

1. The MythBuster Approach: Inviting people to share expert insights about their field through questions about professional clichés and misconceptions
2. The Art of the Follow-Up: Using thoughtful follow-up questions to explore topics deeply rather than jumping between unrelated subjects
3. Cultivating Genuine Curiosity: Demonstrating authentic interest through active listening, non-verbal cues, emotional validation, and appropriate reciprocity

These techniques create the conditions for meaningful conversation without the awkwardness of obviously trying to "go deep." They respect social boundaries while still creating opportunities for genuine connection.

The most meaningful conversations happen when we approach others with genuine curiosity and respect. Rather than trying to extract deep revelations through direct questioning, focus on creating an environment where people naturally want to share more of themselves.

Remember that deepening a conversation is a skill that improves with practice. For sales professionals, having a safe space to rehearse these techniques is crucial for building confidence and mastering the art of the deal. You'll make missteps along the way—we all do. But with each conversation, you'll become more adept at navigating beyond small talk toward the meaningful exchanges that create lasting connections.

So the next time you find yourself stuck in surface level conversations, try one of these techniques. You might be surprised at how naturally the conversation flows into more meaningful territory—no awkward silences or memorized questions required.

After all, the best conversations aren't performances of social skills; they're genuine exchanges between curious minds. And that kind of authentic connection is something we all crave.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best way to move a conversation beyond small talk?

The best way to move beyond small talk is to use natural techniques that encourage others to share more, rather than asking a list of generic "deep questions." Focus on strategies like asking about professional myths (the 'MythBuster' approach), using thoughtful follow-up questions to explore a topic in depth, and showing genuine curiosity through active listening and appropriate reciprocity. These methods create a natural flow that leads to more meaningful exchanges.

How can I ask deep questions without making someone uncomfortable?

You can deepen a conversation without causing discomfort by focusing on professional or passion-related topics instead of prying into personal life. The 'MythBuster' technique is a perfect example. Asking "What's a common myth in your field?" positions the other person as an expert and invites them to share insights without feeling interrogated. This approach respects boundaries while still opening the door to a more substantial discussion.

Why are follow-up questions so important for a good conversation?

Follow-up questions are crucial because they demonstrate that you are actively listening and genuinely interested in what the other person is saying. Research shows that people who ask more follow-up questions are better liked. Instead of jumping between different topics ("going wide"), asking questions like "Can you tell me more about that?" allows you to explore one topic in detail ("going deep"). This builds rapport and encourages the speaker to elaborate, leading to a richer conversation.

What should I do if someone doesn't want to have a deep conversation?

If someone seems hesitant to engage in a deeper conversation, it's important to respect their boundaries and gently steer the conversation back to lighter topics. Pay attention to their verbal and non-verbal cues. If they give short answers or change the subject, don't push. A meaningful connection is built on mutual comfort and respect. The goal is not to force intimacy but to create an environment where it can develop naturally if both parties are willing.

How can I show I'm genuinely curious and not just using a technique?

Genuine curiosity is shown through your behavior, not just your words. It involves practicing active listening, using positive body language, and offering emotional validation. Put your phone away, maintain eye contact, and nod to show you're engaged. Focus on understanding the speaker's perspective rather than just waiting for your turn to talk. When you truly listen and respond to the emotions behind their words (e.g., "That sounds frustrating"), your interest will feel authentic because it is.

Are these conversation techniques only for professional networking?

No, these techniques are versatile and can be adapted for any social situation, from dinner parties and dates to conversations with longtime friends. While the 'MythBuster' approach is excellent for professional settings, the principles of using follow-up questions and showing genuine curiosity are universal. The key is to adapt your approach to the context and your existing relationship with the person, always prioritizing a natural and respectful exchange.

‍